• 2 Posts
  • 288 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 25th, 2023

help-circle


  • I believe we (as in, people) all have a responsibility to hold each other accountable. But we can also only do so much, and inserting yourself into a toxic community …

    Me too, both. That we have responsibility for others and that we are not obliged to put ourselves at harms risk.

    But this is a particularly shitty, maybe wicked problem. There are three groups: A bullies B, and C could stop A, but isn’t bothered by anyone. Now, is C obliged to pick a fight with A, or is B just in bad luck to be born as a B?

    I think here, it is very easy to have strong opinions, while very hard to formulate a concise moral argument. Things get muddier/harder the more we factor reality in.





  • Wouldn’t it be reasonable if another administration get in power and then need to purge all these positions of pro trump people?

    Oh no! You have a great point for horror fans there.

    I’d even say, it probably is somewhat necessary in order to resume administration. What a beautiful, postfactual dilemma:

    The Reps fear an ideological, systemic witch hunt, which they use as an excuse to replace government workers. The new workers are ideologically aligned with the Reps, encouraged to assist the dismantling of non-Rep institutions and carry out the King’s will above and beyond the law.

    Now when votes swing the other way, the new administration kind of has to revert some of this damage to assume functioning.

    Which is where the circle closes; the prophecy fulfills itself. Now the Reps have evidence for their previously baseless claims. The whole system is locked in a back-and-forth mud wrestling of replacing workers based on ideology.




  • Very nice, exactly the signal The Free World needs now. Now, that the previous leader vanished in a puff of Kreml propaganda.

    It’s now more than ever at stake wether Ukraine can fend off the invasion (the outcome of which is another signal to autocrats eyeing future invasions, for example Taiwan, Transnistria*). It’s a question.

    One answer, one possible scenario is that each individual EU country feels overwhelmed to shoulder the additional burden. Or that the Union cannot muster enough support to replace the U.S. This scenario can be self-reinforcing. If it seems likely that the combined response would still be insufficient, a plausible outcome is everybody holding back, which already would favor the Russian aggression.

    So this is why I want to highlight how much good news this is, because it’s exactly the opposite kind of example. Literally stepping up.


    *) Transnistria: Edited thanks to a comment, original wrongly said ‘Tasmania’.






  • Not sure how 0.00006 helmets per capita is the better figure, but there you go.

    Yes, I mean, for Germany, being the 3rd largest economy in the world (only surpassed by the USA and China), it would be a real shame if they were not among the topmost supporters in total. Here, it makes much more sense to use per capita numbers, relate to GDP or whatever. Compared to it’s economic potential, Germany is merely #15 in supporting Ukraine with Denmark, Finland, and the Baltics doing at least twice as much.

    If you deem the bit about the 0…6 helmets per capita to be false, what’s the correct take?


  • Remember how it took like two days to overturn 70 years of precedence of “no weapons delivery into crisis regions”?

    Oh, thanks. Yeah, now I remember making that jump, too, although it took me more than two days. Wild times.

    Hofreiter (Greens) put it quite well … something like … not our ideals have changed, but the world has changed, brutally so.

    I think you did well in dialing back my comment and adding more context, although I still think there was truth in it.





  • Them not being involved in the peace talks underlines again how indispensable nuclear weapons are, sadly.

    The DSA playing hopscotch with whose ally they are underlines how worthless a shared nuclear umbrella can be.

    So a grim lesson for Ukraine, Europe, Taiwan and pretty much any country with any border tensions, or anything another aspiring imperialist might find desireable: Get nukes, own them yourselfes, or risk being thrown aside or being steamrolled. Trump undoing decades of existential anti-proliferation work in mere days.