• 7 Posts
  • 66 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: January 6th, 2023

help-circle





  • Not Mary Sues:

    Kirk: repeatedly impresses god-like beings with his emotional maturity and reasoning. Fought hand-to-hand with Khan and won. Saved the whales.

    Picard: passes Q’s trials and makes a case for humanity’s worth, multiple times. Proves Data’s person-hood. Survives Carassian torture by sheer willpower.

    Sisko: chosen as the Emissary. Does wrong and suffers no consequences.

    Janeway: holds fast to Federation principles even when it prevents her from getting home; gets home anyway.

    Archer: so important that Daniels and the Xindi both fight over him. Ends the Temporal Cold War and founds the Federation.

    Mary Sue:

    Burnham: starts the Klingon war, freed from prison by a Terran who uses her as a pawn. Gets called out for breaking rules.

    Is this right, @Akuchimoya@startrek.website ?













  • Overwriting canon is fine, actually. TOS never had an issue with it, and PIC S1E10 gave Data a much better send-off by breaking canon from Nemesis and other Soong episodes. Gene Roddenberry’s assistant officially decanonized TAS, but better writers still acknowledge it.

    The idea of “canon” in regard to fictional worlds is dubious anyway, especially ones developed across multiple writers and generations. I’m fine with stuffing Pike’s comment about women on the bridge into the dustbin of history, and not stressing about what decade the Eugenics Wars happened, and assuming PIC S3 doesn’t exist.