Thought the 1st season was pretty good, 7/10 normal rating, 9/10 IMDB-style rating. Never read the books (don’t know why), so that didn’t colour anything. Very excited to watch the new season, though I don’t even know when, our backlog is currently the final 3 episodes of BSG rewatch, Succession, From, Silo. Good thing it comes out weekly, that way there’s no rush to start it ;)
7/10 when an average show is 5/10, 9/10 when the whole rating skews towards high values, on IMDB anything average gets 7-8 points.